I just celebrated my birthday about a month ago, and received the obligatory birthday wishes on my Facebook wall. It makes me happy to see all those birthday wishes. I’m a bit of a ham when it comes to my own birthday celebrations. But for Vikki Ortiz Healy over at the Chicago Tribune, such Facebook wishes are a plight of insincerity in the digital era.
I completely understand where she’s coming from. E-cards only count for so much, depending on who sent them. And Facebook wall greetings seem even less sincere because Facebook alerts you to every upcoming and current birthday for your entire social graph. That’s right. All those people that left wonderful wall greetings on your birthday didn’t even have to try to remember the occasion–Facebook did all the work for them.
But is this really any different from the other random people in your life wishing you well on your day of birth? What about that bouncer that checked your I.D. as you entered the club, and, noticing your birthday coincided with the current date, wished you a happy birthday? Or the friendly mailman that waved happy birthday to you after he noticed all the cards and coupons that suddenly filled your mailbox?
Let’s bring it a little closer to home. Your coworkers typically know your birthday, and sometimes your neighbors do as well. Sure, you see all of these people in person, but they still may have offered up their birthday greetings out of obligation instead of sincerity.
Fixing The Proximity Dilemma
Face it. Facebook is the new water cooler. We as humans have a tendency to associate with people due to our proximity to them. We chat with our neighbors because they live on the same street as we do, and we see them all the time. We chat with our coworkers because they work on the same floor and eat lunch at the same time as we do.
Sure, it seems weird that your 8th grade classmate hit you up on Facebook. But if that same classmate had gone to the same high school and college, and lived nearby 20 years later, there’s an increased likelihood that the two of you would have kept in touch. Not to say that you’d be best friends, but your proximity to each other would have increase the potential for you to continuously cross paths. These intersections of our lives give us opportunities to catch up with our acquaintances, see what’s going on in each other’s lives, and then move on.
What Facebook does is remove a portion of the proximity dilemma, giving you the opportunity to stay close to each other in the virtual sense. You see friends’ updates and the photos of their Cabo vacation. You’re able to remain digitally close to 8th grade classmates because you have access to their shared moments in life. Facebook extends the concept of building relationships around proximity, as the very definition of proximity is forever changed with the introduction of social networking.
Further driving this change is the mobile realm, making proximity acutely irrelevant for the purpose of accessing one’s shared content. If you have the mobile web, then you have the ability to view those photos directly from your phone, keeping you at arm’s length from your Facebook contacts.
I’m not saying that your entire social awareness will be forever changed, and that physical interaction can be completely replaced with status updates and photo albums. But I think Facbook has been around long enough for us to recognize its game-changing potential.
Monetizing Proximity
Even more interesting is the monetization of this virtual proximity. In automating certain aspects of your social interaction, Facebook becomes a personal assistant of sorts, cultivating your relationships through a program. We as consumers appreciate the convenience of not having to remember birthdays or manually mark them on a calendar. Those acquaintances we’ve reconnected with on Facebook may be important to us, but not important enough to go out of our way. What’s more fitting than a casual greeting on their Facebook wall? And what’s more convenient than a $1 virtual gift to post along with it?
Through Facebook’s platform, the company provides applications access to certain public information, which could very well include a birth date, and even an associated event. From there the automation of our relationships can be furthered with application integration, providing wish lists, a wide array of virtual gifts and the ability to link this Facebook data with other sites and services. Link it to a mobile payments service and you can receive a birthday reminder with the ability to purchase and post a virtual gift just by sending a mobile text message.
Like I said. Convenient. And lucrative.
Social networks first reflect the way in which we already communicate with each other. They then reflect the desires we have to improve on that communication. Even though there are ways to make money from these desires, the expansive communication options presented to end users are usually worth it. Perhaps it’s all just sincere enough.


8 Comments »













Don’t forget about sending REAL gifts, instead of just virtual gifts! RealGifts are freshly integrated into the new Facebook Gift Shop as well. Check it out by clicking the Gifts icon on anybody’s profile, then clicking Real Gifts.
i wish that facebook had existed when i was in school / uni, i think my social life would have been sooo much better!
So don’t list your birthday on your profile. What a concept.
I’m sure there are still trillions of websites out there if Facebook went away tomorrow. I don’t get people who do literally everything on there. It’s so limiting.
I disagree with Ortiz. I loved getting all the bday greetings! I didn’t have some “pie-in-the-sky” notion that these people actually remembered my birthday–I knew FB reminded them; however, I never would’ve heard from them at all had it not been for FB!
Facebook has put me in touch with and given me the ability to keep up with those 8th grade classmates I would never know anything about otherwise. It has definitely enhanced the relationships that surely would’ve disappeared from my life completely!
Facebook facilitate the visitors more and more to pay(real transaction)some thing here.
This is leading to make it a shopping place.
I disagree with Damo - yes there are other sites, but they are not like Facebook. The web has been around for a long time now but do people you knew long ago google you to reinstate a friendship with you (in my case, yes, twice) and then if so, do they keep it up - on a website? or is it by email. and emailing others.. it there are a lot of others.. I write *long.* and then get burned out. on the writing, not on the friends.
On Facebook you can stay in contact by little status updates which can lead to conversations shared by many (depending on settings)
The only thing I hate is the inability to archive. I used to save email in lieu of a diary, and now i facebook and it just goes off into the past stream.
And yeah, I don’t post my birthday on facebook. But if you do skip the gifts and cards and try memory book. It’s not an app. My friends use Notes, tag some friends and/or publish it in their streams, and just say Remind me of something we did that you remember. (or even something you did that they remember). It can even lead to group reminiscing. Even if you are thousands of miles (and years) away.
Ortiz is wrong. You are right.
I don’t buy into the insincerity argument over Facebook birthday reminders.
For years… no make that almost 2 decades (now I’m feeling old), I’ve used some kind of digital calendar and I’ve always made a point to enter birthday reminders, and I never felt that it was any different than what my grandparents did — they had a paper calendar hanging on their kitchen wall with all their friends and family, the children, the grand children, and all their birthdays there as reminders. And every year, at some point during the holidays, my grandmother would sit down at the breakfast table with a new calendar and transfer everyones birthdays from the old calendar to the new one.
Just because it is digital does not make it any less sincere, only more efficient. This is the sort of thing everyone has always done.
(I’m here because Simon Mainwaring @simonmainwaring Tweeted this article.)